NYC Bodega Breakfast Sandwiches

One of the best parts of my holiday break was a little stay-cation Matt and I took for about three days between Christmas and New Year’s. We booked a hotel in the East Village, made a bunch of restaurant reservations*, explored an independent bookstore, found some really cute bars, went to a cat cafe (swoon!), braved a bad rainstorm to get to Kalustyan’s (totally worth it!), and just generally enjoyed a few days off.

Believe it or not, I actually brought my laptop with me and had planned to post at least one or two blog posts while we were “away”, and this one was my top priority. I’d even planned out what to write – like, oh hey, I’m in NYC for a few days and have easy access to these iconic bodega sandwiches, woohoo go me.

But, two problems emerged with that little plan: 1) our hotel was nowhere near a bodega, so we didn’t end up eating any of these; and 2) more importantly, I forgot to download the pictures off my camera before we left home. So, yeah…

It’s all good, I’m here now. And whether you live next door to an NYC bodega or you’ve never heard of these even once, it matters not, because we all need this recipe. These are incredibly fun to make at home, unbelievably delicious, and a little bird told me they are a foolproof hangover cure (wink).

Sometimes, I think we all need a little New York in our lives. The kitchen is good for that. And this is one amazing breakfast sandwich. Enjoy!

Source: recipe from Lucinda Scala Quinn, found on Martha Stewart

Ingredients:
1 everything bagel, or other bagel of choice, cut in half and toasted
1 tbs unsalted butter, plus more for buttering bagel
2 large eggs
1 deli slice of American cheese
2 to 3 slices cooked bacon
Hot sauce and/or ketchup, for serving (after testing a few hot sauces, we determined Frank’s RedHot Original to be the winner)

Directions:
Butter cut sides of each bagel half. Set aside.
Meanwhile, heat a cast-iron or nonstick skillet over medium-high. Add butter to skillet. Carefully crack both eggs into skillet. When whites begin to set, immediately puncture yolks. If they don’t do so on their own, spread the yolks around a little.
Top one egg with cheese, then bacon. Flip remaining egg, yolk-side down, on top of bacon (like an egg-on-egg sandwich). Transfer eggs onto one toasted half of the bagel (this seems to take 2 spatulas, just FYI); top with remaining bagel half and lightly press together. Use a serrated knife to cut the sandwich in half, then serve immediately with hot sauce or ketchup, or wrap halfway in parchment paper or aluminum foil for a portable breakfast.

Serving size: 1 breakfast sandwich, can be multiplied up easily

*Restaurant Recommendations:
Gato NYC
Stanton Social
Ngam
Blue Smoke
Sushi Samba
Mighty Quinn’s Barbecue

Note: this post is not sponsored in any way, the aforementioned staycation was paid for in full by the author and her husband. Links are provided for reader curiosity/information only.

2 responses to “NYC Bodega Breakfast Sandwiches

  1. The cat cafe is so neat, isn’t it?!! My daughter surprised me with a reservation there one afternoon when I was visiting her in November and I had so much fun! Kalustyans is also so much fun. Wish I had bought more goodies! I’ve never heard of a bodega sandwich so thanks for this post!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *